This recipe for Amish Pasta Salad is one of our most popular recipes. It has wonderful reviews and has been a family favorite for many years. It’s perfect to take to any gathering. Every event I have ever taken this delicious salad too, I come home with an empty pan. I can eat this pasta salad for breakfast! We hope it becomes one of your family favorites, too. You might also enjoy our recipe for maple baked beans with sausage as another great side dish.
Every time I post this recipe I get asked “Can I leave the sugar out”.. of course you can, but in my opinion the dish won’t be as good. The ingredients in this salad go together very well and that is what makes it such a hit. All recipes are versatile and I always urge people to make the recipe “their own”, but this pasta salad is excellent the way it is written. You can add a meat if you like, such as cooked chicken, diced ham, tuna or shrimp. If the pasta gets dry after a day or so, just add more mayonnaise.
The other most common question“What mayonnaise do you use?”.. Dukes.. we always use Dukes!
Recipe feedback: “This is the best recipe. My whole family will eat it even the picky ones. By far my favorite pasta salad. Thank you.” – Kim
“Wow this pasta salad is amazing! I made it on the weekend and we just loved it. The recipe is a keeper for sure.” – Karen
“I made this delicious pasta salad this weekend and it is so good!! Reminds me of my Amish Grandmother’s salad and no one had the recipe all these years! Thank you so much for your wonderful recipes!” – Teresa
“This is my favorite recipe for making Amish Macaroni Salad! I added a red pepper, chopped, because I didn’t have pimentos. Also, added thawed, frozen peas. Amazing!!! My mother asks me to make it for every family gathering . She even wanted it for her birthday as her present!! I have had to triple the recipe since everyone wants to take some home. Thank you for your great recipes. I use them all the time!” – Sherri
Did you know we have eBooks? Each of our Ebooks is a collection of our most popular recipes. You will have them at your fingertips and can pull them up at any time. It’s a nice and convenient way to enjoy our recipes instead of having to search a database. You can purchase each Ebook individually or buy the bundle. Visit our shop HERE!
Full recipe in the recipe card below.
Are you reading our digital magazine,Front Porch Life? It’s full of great new recipes, country living, fantastic people, southern charm, cooking tips and so much more. We send it directly to your email so you can start reading, cooking and relaxingimmediately! This is our premium content not found on our website. Join 1000’s of others today and start enjoying our magazine!
Amish Pasta Salad
Judy Yeager
This Amish Pasta Salad is a creamy delicious salad that is great for any occasion. We serve it year round and it has 100's of reviews. Great pasta salad for Easter, Christmas or any holiday.
4.69 from 85 votes
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 15 minutesmins
Cook Time 10 minutesmins
Total Time 25 minutesmins
Course Salad
Cuisine American, southern
Servings 12cups
Ingredients
116 ounce box medium shell pasta, uncooked
5eggshard-boiled and chopped
1cupcelery chopped
1/2cupsweet onionchopped
12 ounce jar pimentos drained
1cupgreen pepper chopped
3tablespoonssweet pickle relish drained
1/4teaspoongarlic powder
1/2teaspoonpaprika
1/4teaspoonblack pepper
1/2teaspooncelery seed
1 1/2cupsmayonnaise
1/2cupsour cream
1/4cupsugar
2tablespoonsyellow mustard
3teaspoonsapple cider vinegar
Instructions
Cook pasta according to package directions and drain.
In a large bowl mix pasta, eggs, onion, pimentos, celery, green pepper and relish. In another bowl mix garlic powder, paprika, black pepper, celery seed, mayonnaise, sour cream, sugar, mustard and vinegar.
Pour the mayonnaise mixture over the pasta and mix well. Can sprinkle with more paprika. Chill in refrigerator several hours or overnight. This makes about 12 cups and keeps well in the refrigerator for several days.
Video
Notes
If pasta salad gets dry after a day or so add more mayo, you could also add tuna, chicken or ham to this recipe.
The key to the best creamy pasta salad is to rinse the cooked pasta under cold water before tossing it with the dressing. Skipping this step means the dressing will be sticky.
Cook the pasta al dente: Al dente pasta is firmer and less likely to become mushy or soggy when mixed with other ingredients. Rinse the pasta with cold water after cooking: This helps to remove excess starch and cool the pasta, which can help to prevent it from becoming soggy.
I find that the higher time range listed on box instructions is usually just about right for pasta salad. Let your pasta cool completely before tossing it with the other ingredients. If it's still warm, the hot pasta will start to cook and wilt the veggies.
If you're making a dish that will be served chilled or at room temp—think cold soba, rice noodles, pasta salad—you do want to rinse so that you get toothsome (sorry) individual strands rather than one big gummy clump. Certain types of noodles benefit from a rinse in almost all applications.
Vinegar and other acidic ingredients do strange things to the flavor of pasta when used in salad-level amounts. Ever notice an irritating acerbic aftertaste just about every time you've eaten pasta salad? That's the vinegar announcing itself, and it's not pleasant.
Pasta absorbs liquids, because it is made of starch, and starch absorbs water. Tossing the pasta with oil will reduce the absorption, by coating them in a water-repellent layer. Beyond this, the solution is simple: don't drain as much water from the cooked pasta, and add more dressing.
Depends on what kind of pasta salad you are making. I dress WARM/Hot pasta with vinaigrette type dressings right away-absorb great !. Cooled/ room temp pasta w/ mayo type dressing. I NEVER rinse this pasta.
An important thing to remember about pasta is that it hardens and gets chewy as it cools. Since it's not being served hot or with sauce, the pasta benefits from an extra minute of cooking, but don't let it get mushy. For a well-cooked pasta salad, plan to cook the pasta until just past al dente.
The key to keeping macaroni salad from drying out is the pasta. If you don't cook it enough, the pasta won't grab on to the dressing and will dry out. If you overcook the pasta, it will be completely soggy and gross. Cook the pasta just right, and your macaroni salad will stay perfectly creamy.
But today, I am going to teach you how to make a salad without using a recipe so you, too, can become a salad artist. Sound like a deal? There are five elements to a perfect salad: greens, sweetness, creaminess, crunchiness, and dressing. Let's talk about each one.
Introduction: My name is Francesca Jacobs Ret, I am a innocent, super, beautiful, charming, lucky, gentle, clever person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.
We notice you're using an ad blocker
Without advertising income, we can't keep making this site awesome for you.
Judy Yeager
